Skip to main content

Is India arming itself to become a Hindu State?

Credit: NBC
India, the second most populous country in the world, is host to a multitude of cultures and identities. 80% of the population identify as Hindus, the largest religion by far in India, whilst a respectable 14.2% of the population identify as Muslims. The large gap in population has slowly begun to lead to an ever larger gap in political inequality, with the current BJP government pushing a Pro-Hinduist sentiment across the country. This has raised the question - Is India slowly transforming into a Hindu State, and what are the risks of this?
The History
The Muslim minority had become a focal point of Modi’s campaign, with his goals of promoting secularism and ‘Indian’ identity for civillians, regardless of their descent or religion. Historically, Hinduism is the largest religion in the country - but this began to change with the advent of mass migration from surrounding Muslim countries into India. These immigrants consisted of Muslims seeking both economic opportunities, and shelter from persecution (such as Rohingya Muslims).
Yet, this secular narrative began to change when Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s party, the BJP (Bharatiya Janata Party) rose to power . Their imposition of a lockdown on Kashmir marked the beginning of the BJP’s attempts to create a Hindu state. This act was motivated to protect Kashmiri civilians and strengthen Indian territorial claims over the disputed land, as well as instill a strong sense of Hindu/Indian nationalism over this region. This consequently led to a rise of Hindu supremacy, enforcing a strong sense of Hinduism across the sub-continent. Notably, there has been a dramatic increase in crimes against Muslims, as well as the onslaught of cow vigilantes on Muslim cow farmers. 
Finally, the Citizenship Amendment Bill signified to India Modi’s strong intent for a unified, Hindu state. The bill makes it harder for Muslims to gain citizenship in one of the four possible ways, and register in the National Register of Citizens. Many claim this is to curb mass immigration that is changing the demographics of the country, whilst many others, especially students, speculate this is to drive out Muslims who have immigrated to India from neighboring countries, and create a Hindu nation-state. https://aglobalinjustice.blogspot.com/2020/02/the-citizenship-amendment-bill-cab.html This article offers a detailed explanation of the impacts and motivations of the landmark bill. 
The Opinions
Supporters - Supporters of Modi’s Hindu regime claim that not only is a majority of Hindu in politics and decision-making branches important, but the most stable in terms of catering to the needs of civilians. Students and Indians in rural areas have expressed strong support for Modi’s intent of a Hindu rashtra, as they claim it will pave the way for a more unified and stronger India. Needless to say, Islamophobia and Xenophobia play a big role in this mindset. 
Critics - Critics of Modi’s Hindu Rashtra speculate that this will be a direct attack on secularism and diversity in the country - something that Modi’s predecessors have worked hard to build and establish. Moreover, they fear that this growing Hindu supremacy will indicate a revival of discrimination and segregation similar to the Caste System.
The Answer
Identity is a controversial part of politics - it is why there is no right or wrong answer to the question of “Is this course of action ethical?” However, it is undeniable that Modi intends shape the demographics of his country, whether it be for a more unified/stronger country, or to reduce the inflow of Muslim immigrants and refugees into India. 
However, the controversial laws passed have caused many to take to the streets to demand reforms or express support, and led to heavy civilian loss and massive lockdowns. Covid 19 has changed this, but the narrative remains the same. 
The largest fear by far has been the xenophobic and hindu supremacy these BJP actions might imply - however more concerning is the effect of this on the legality system in India. Experts fear that government and societal pressure could sway Judicial Systems in India regarding the validity of the Citizenship Amendment Act, and perhaps compromise on secularism in the country. However, only time can tell the real impacts of this change in Indian domestic policy.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Is Kamala Harris a prosecutor for the people?

Presidential Candidate Joe Biden revealed on Tuesday afternoon that he had chosen California Senator Kamala Harris as his running mate for Vice President. This announcement sparked an outpouring of responses - many hailed Harris as a favorable choice given her experience as a U.S. senator, having already been put through the media wringer as a former presidential candidate, and being the first woman of color ever to be a part of a major party’s presidential ticket. Harris, the daughter of Jamaican and Indian immigrants, is Black and Asian-American.  But contrary to the Democratic establishment’s promotion of Harris's vice presidential candidacy, a substantial cohort of progressives and liberals greeted the news with critiques of her career, both as a prosecutor and lawmaking Senator. From denying affirming healthcare to a trans inmate to barring forums sex workers used to protect themselves, the former “ top cop ” has a concerning record of endangering the American community’s most...
Post a Comment
Read more

Cancel Culture : Necessary or Out of Hand?

From singers to athletes to politicians to YouTubers and celebrities, many individuals have been “cancelled” in today’s world. Celebrities and social media influencers face the “cancel culture” the most as a result of their controversial actions, opinions and statements, predominantly from their past. The concept of “cancelling” someone refers to their online shaming and public boycotting by the masses, usually on social media which results in them facing major backlash from millennials and Gen Z. Today, many believe that the biggest endorser of this cancel culture is President Donald Trump himself against anyone who speaks against him or his actions.  History The movement to boycott an individual and essentially shame them online, rose to prominence in 2017 when the younger generations began calling out celebrities and influencers on their offensive language and action from the past. This has resulted in the mass shaming of numerous individuals over the years.  YouTubers, act...
Post a Comment
Read more

Why is Hollywood immune to the #MeToo movement?

Fueled by the persistent gender inequalities and attitudes about gender and sexuality, our social environment has evolved to represent something that knowingly allows sexual violence to be normalized and justified. With the rise of the #MeToo movement, the eyes of feminists have been on Hollywood. Feminists around the world describe a “ matrix of sexism ” in which elements of rape culture in cinema have formed a taken-for-granted backdrop to their everyday lives. We readily discuss examples we witness through cinema and TV, including victim-blaming, “slut-shaming,” rape jokes, the celebration of male sexual conquest, and demeaning sexualized representations of women.  Rape culture and sexual assault have ingrained into the lives of anybody with a Netflix subscription or ticket from their local movie theater. With recent social media upsurge over a Polish Film, 365 days , many viewers around the world criticized Netflix for providing a platform for ‘cinema’ that romanticizes kidnap...
Post a Comment
Read more